Inbox Trust is Earned: A Technical & Strategic Guide to Cold + Nurturing Email Warm-Up
- SamB
- May 7
- 18 min read
Updated: Jun 4
“Land. Engage. Don’t Get Burned.”
So imagine you have run email campaigns, the kind you’re proud of. Thoughtful segmentation, beautifully written messaging, some signal based personalization, a solid lead list. But something was off. Despite everything being “by the book,” the open rate barely touched 8%. That’s when you traced the problem: poor email warm-up. A technical gap masquerading as a marketing failure.
Leading the engineering, operations and marketing functions in multiple permutation combinations has given me a has taught me that every great email strategy is only as strong as its technical foundation.. I’ve learned that even the best email strategy will fall flat if the underlying infrastructure isn’t tuned for deliverability.
Email warm-up is not just a “nice-to-have” hygiene step - it’s the gateway to inbox trust.
Yet most teams treat it as an afterthought. This article is for founders, marketers, sales leaders, and tech heads who want their emails to land, be read, and convert, not disappear silently into spam folders.
Table of Content
Section 1: What is Email Warm-Up - and Why It’s Widely Misunderstood
The term “email warm-up” often gets lumped into vague prep work - a few test sends, maybe some soft intros to coworkers. But in reality, email warm-up is about building credibility with inbox providers like Gmail, Outlook, Microsoft and Yahoo.
Warm-up is the process of gradually building a sender reputation for your email domain and/or IP address. It signals to spam filters:
“I’m a real sender. My recipients engage. I’m not a threat.”
Think of it like trying to build a credit score. If you suddenly apply for a large loan with no payment history, you’re flagged. Similarly, if your domain suddenly starts sending hundreds or thousands of emails with no prior activity, inbox providers get suspicious - and your deliverability tanks.
What most teams don’t realize is:
It’s not just how many emails you send - it’s how people engage with them.
Warm-up isn’t a one-time activity - it’s a reputation strategy that must be maintained.
You can burn a domain permanently by skipping it.
That’s why campaigns with great content often get ghosted - not always because the messaging was bad, but because the tech wasn't trusted.
Section 2: The Technical Foundation - What Inbox Algorithms Actually See
Let’s get into the backend, because warm-up is as much an engineering concern as a marketing one.
Here’s what mailbox providers care about:
✅ Domain Authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
These protocols verify that your email is really coming from you. If even one of these is missing or misconfigured, you’re already starting with a red flag.
📈 Reputation Signals
Your domain/IP builds a score over time, influenced by:
Bounce rates
Spam complaints
Open & reply rates
Send frequency
List hygiene
A new domain starts with zero reputation. Sending 1,000 emails from it is like shouting in a room full of strangers - they won’t trust you.
🧠 Behavioral Data from Recipients
Inbox providers track how recipients interact:
Do they open?
Do they reply?
Do they move it out of spam?
These signals tell providers if your emails are wanted. During warm-up, your focus should be on getting opens and replies, not conversions.
Section 3: When Warm-Up Is Ignored - Common Mistakes That Hurt Deliverability
Despite being mission-critical, warm-up is often overlooked - especially in early-stage teams or aggressive outbound campaigns. Here are the most common missteps I’ve seen (and sometimes made myself):
❌ 1. Blasting from a Cold Domain
The number one mistake: taking a brand-new domain and sending hundreds or thousands of emails on Day 1. This is an immediate red flag for inbox providers. Even if you’re sending to a legitimate list, the sudden volume looks spammy.
❌ 2. Skipping DNS Setup
Without proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC configurations, you’re essentially sending mail that can’t be verified. That’s like knocking on someone’s door without showing your face - they’ll slam it shut (or in this case, relegate you to spam).
❌ 3. Treating Warm-Up as a Checkbox
A few test emails to internal addresses don’t cut it. Real warm-up requires real engagement. Providers need to see that recipients outside your domain are opening, clicking, and ideally replying.
❌ 4. Using One Domain for Everything
Mixing cold outreach, newsletters, and transactional emails on the same domain can create chaos. If your outreach gets flagged, even your invoices might start landing in spam. Always segment functions - use subdomains or alternate domains where necessary.
❌ 5. Not Monitoring Performance During Ramp-Up
Most teams “set it and forget it.” But warm-up is a dynamic process. You need to watch open rates, bounce rates, and spam complaints every day during the early phase. If something tanks, stop, re-evaluate, and adjust volume.
Section 4: A Proven Email Warm-Up Cadence That Works
Having learned the hard way, here’s a simple, structured framework we now use across campaigns. Whether you're warming up a new domain or reviving a cold one, this applies.
Email warm-up isn’t just a checkbox before sending your campaigns - it’s reputation engineering. Think of it as laying down the tracks before you try to run a train. Rush this step, and you're not just hurting one campaign - you're risking the long-term trustworthiness of your entire domain.
In our team, we’ve seen everything from enthusiastic SDRs launching 500-email blasts on Day 1 to marketers using beautifully designed templates that never even reached the inbox. What fixed this? A structured warm-up approach grounded in tech hygiene and human behavior.
Here’s the real-world warm-up framework we use, complete with variations and lessons from experience.
🟣 Phase 1: Foundation & Manual Warm-Up (Days 1–5)
Objective: Get the basics right. No amount of warm-up works if your foundation is broken.
Action Points:
Set up at least 3 to 5 subdomains or custom domains for outreach [never blast from your main domain.]
✅ Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records correctly. Triple-check.
✅ Age your domain - avoid sending high volume from domains less than 2–3 weeks old.
✅ Set up inboxes using Gmail or Outlook. Make them look real: name, profile photo, signature.
✅ Start sending 10–15 emails/ day to known contacts who will reply - friends, team, vendors.
Category | Explanation |
Recipients | Friends, team members, vendor contacts, ex-colleagues - people who will open + reply. Use personal networks to simulate natural, friendly conversation. |
Recipient Domains | Mostly public domains like Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo - these are the ones major spam filters watch closely. Avoid corporate domains at this point. |
Inboxes Used | Use 1–2 inboxes on your warm-up subdomain (e.g., john@hello.yourdomain.com) |
Daily Volume | Start with 10–20 emails per inbox per day |
✅ Tip: Create reply loops: Send → get a reply → reply back - this builds engagement history.
Real-Life Tip: We once tested warming up using dummy inboxes with no engagement. Didn’t work. Then we had real team members exchange short, non-promotional emails ("Hey, did you check this out?") - and saw a 15–20% lift in inbox placement over two weeks.
🟣 Phase 2: Gradual Ramp-Up & Warm-Up Automation (Days 6–15)
Objective: Train inbox providers to expect consistent, trustworthy volume.
Action Points:
Scale volume incrementally - e.g., 20 → 50 → 100 → 200 per day.
Rotate between 2–3 inboxes or even domains (if running multiple campaigns).
Use tools like MailReach, Warmup Inbox, Lemwarm, or Instantly to automate warm-up flows.
Still prioritize engagement-heavy emails - keep them conversational, short, and plain-text.
Category | Explanation |
Recipients | Use automated warm-up tools (Mailreach, Lemwarm, Lemlist, Instantly, etc.) that send to a network of warmed-up inboxes (these will automatically reply). |
Recipient Domains | Mix of public and business domains (e.g., gmail.com, outlook.com, company.com). This helps build versatility and simulate real inbox diversity. |
Inboxes Used | 2–3 inboxes per domain. If possible, use 1–2 domains to reduce risk (e.g., outbound.yourdomain.com, connectyourbrand.com). |
Daily Volume | Increase to 40–80 emails/day per inbox, gradually. Maintain reply patterns and low bounce rates. |
✅ Variation Tip: You can create burner domains for cold outreach (e.g., getyourbrand.com) that route replies to your main inbox. Keeps your core domain reputation safe.
Real-Life Nuance: We once used a beautifully designed HTML newsletter during ramp-up. It got flagged. Switching to plain-text conversational templates - “Hey John, quick question for you…” - improved both open and reply rates. During warm-up, inboxes trust human-sounding emails more than polished marketing assets.
🟣 Phase 3: Engagement Focus & Early Prospecting (Days 16–30)
Objective: Show inbox providers you’re sending valuable, wanted content.
Action Points:
Start introducing actual prospecting emails (still low volume).
Use personalization tokens: name, location, industry references.
Avoid links and images initially - gradually introduce them.
Continue watching deliverability metrics: bounce rate, open rate, and spam complaints.
Category | Explanation |
Recipients | Highly targeted, smaller segment of your cold audience. Prioritize those most likely to engage (e.g., matched ICPs, prior webinar attendees, lookalikes). |
Recipient Domains | Gradually introduce corporate domains (e.g., @acmecorp.com, @enterprise.org). These have stricter filters - go slow & cautious. |
Inboxes Used | Use 4–10 inboxes across 2–5 domains. Use different variations like: |
connect@yourbrandmail.com | | Daily Volume | Max 150–200/ day per domain, split across inboxes. Monitor engagement and spam reports closely. |
✅ Important: Keep openers and responders in warm sequences. Suppress non-engagers from follow-ups after 3–4 touches.
Real-Life Variation: We stagger outreach to include a mix of value-based content (e.g., blog links, insights, invites) alongside traditional cold emails. The key is that it looks natural. If 100% of your emails are “hard sell,” expect a drop in reputation.
🟣 Phase 4: Maintenance Mode (Ongoing)
Objective: Protect your reputation and keep inbox placement high.
Action Points:
Avoid sudden volume spikes - keep sends consistent.
Monitor health using Google Postmaster Tools, SNDS, or warm-up dashboards.
Regularly clean your list - remove unresponsive contacts every 30–45 days.
Mix your sends - cold, nurture, customer success, announcements.
Real-Life Insight: Even with a warmed-up domain, we once saw open rates tank after a one-time volume spike triggered by a product launch campaign. Now, we ramp big campaigns slowly, even if the domain is “ready.” Trust takes time to build - and seconds to lose.
🧮 Any difference between cold emails and nurturing email campaigns?
Yes - cold emails and nurturing email campaigns serve different purposes, follow different strategies, and have very different technical and engagement expectations.
Here’s a side-by-side breakdown of the key differences you should know - especially useful when managing both outreach and lifecycle campaigns as you do:
🧊 Cold Emails vs 🤝 Nurturing Emails
Aspect | Cold Emails | Nurturing Emails |
Audience | Cold prospects (no prior relationship) | Warm leads, existing contacts, or customers |
Goal | Initiate interest, start a conversation | Build trust, educate, guide toward conversion |
Tone | Brief, direct, personalized to spark curiosity | Informative, value-driven, aligned with funnel stage |
Email Type | One-to-one, plain text, highly personalized | One-to-many, may include branding and design |
Send Volume | Low to medium (high volume = risk) | Medium to high (with consent and engagement history) |
Sending Domain Strategy | Often from separate or subdomains; requires careful warm-up | Sent from primary or marketing subdomain with established reputation |
Content | Icebreakers, pain-point led, social proof | Guides, updates, event invites, product tips |
CTA | Book a call, reply to this email | Download asset, read blog, attend webinar, upgrade plan |
Tools Used | Outreach tools (Apollo, Lemlist, Instantly, Smartlead) | Marketing automation (HubSpot, ActiveCampaign, Mailchimp, Customer.io) |
Spam Risk | High (if warm-up skipped or wrong audience) | Low (with opt-in and healthy engagement) |
Compliance | Must follow cold outreach regulations (CAN-SPAM, GDPR where applicable) | Must comply with opt-in laws (GDPR, CASL, etc.) |
⚠️ Why This Matters in Warm-Up and Deliverability:
Cold emails need warmer infrastructure You can’t send 1,000 cold emails from the same domain where your invoices or transactional emails go. One spam trigger and everything gets flagged.
Nurture campaigns build long-term sender health High open and click rates in nurturing campaigns signal to inbox providers that your domain sends valuable, welcomed content.
Treat each type as its own ecosystem Cold = more technical diligence Nurture = more content strategy + engagement consistency
📌 Domain Strategy: Primary vs. Custom vs. Burner
Type | Use Case | Pros | Cons |
Primary Domain (e.g., yourbrand.com) | Newsletters, nurturing, inbound replies, customer emails | Strong brand trust, centralized | Risk of damaging reputation if cold email goes wrong |
Subdomain (e.g., outreach.yourbrand.com) | Cold campaigns, SDR outreach | Safe separation from core infra | Still linked to parent domain, partial reputation impact |
Custom/Alternate Domain (e.g., getbrandmail.com) | Aggressive outbound, list-based prospecting | Safe to burn/rotate, less risky | Requires warming up from scratch, may need redirects |
Free/Public Domains (e.g., Gmail, Outlook) | Warm-up only, not for scaling | Fast to set up, low initial risk |
HTML vs Plain Text?
✅ Does HTML body Work for Nurturing Campaigns?
For nurturing campaigns, using properly designed HTML emails is not only acceptable but often preferred, provided you follow best practices. Here’s a quick breakdown of when and why HTML is the better choice, and where you still need to be careful:
Reason | Benefit |
Established Relationship | Since recipients have opted in or previously engaged, inbox providers are more lenient with styling and media. |
Branding | HTML lets you reflect your visual identity - logos, color schemes, banners, etc. |
Content Structure | Great for newsletters, product updates, educational content with sections. |
Tracking | HTML allows for tracking opens, clicks, and engagement more accurately. |
Visual CTAs | Buttons and structured layouts increase the chance of interaction when done right. |
⚠️ HTML Email Best Practices (To Avoid Spam Filters)
Even with nurturing (not cold), bad HTML can kill your deliverability. Here’s what to watch:
Keep code clean and minimal
Use inline styles, not embedded CSS
Avoid Word-generated HTML or bloated builders
Use responsive design (mobile-first if possible)
Limit the use of images
Don’t make your entire email an image
Always use ALT text
Maintain a healthy text-to-image ratio
Avoid spammy elements
No "Click here!!!", all caps, or deceptive subject lines
Don’t use red fonts, JavaScript, or embedded forms
Always include a plain-text version
Helps non-HTML-friendly inboxes (and improves reputation)
Most email marketing platforms auto-generate this - check it
Optimize load time
Compress images
Avoid large attachments or external fonts
Test across devices and platforms
Use tools like Litmus or Email on Acid to preview across Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail, etc.
✔ Use HTML for nurturing - but do it cleanly, lightly, and smartly. ✖ Try not to use HTML for cold emails - they’ll almost certainly get flagged.
❌ Why HTML Doesn’t Work Well for Cold Emails
Here’s what inbox providers see when you send HTML in a cold email:
Issue | Why It’s a Problem |
Looks like marketing/promotional content | Spam filters associate HTML (especially with buttons, images, and bold styling) with bulk marketing — not personal 1:1 emails. |
Heavier code triggers filters | Complex HTML emails often contain styles, scripts, or hidden tags that are spam triggers. |
Lower trust factor | Cold recipients are less likely to trust flashy emails — plain-text mimics natural human communication. |
Inbox placement worsens | HTML increases the chance of being routed to the Promotions, Updates, or worse — the Spam folder. |
Open tracking pixels can backfire | Embedded pixels in HTML (for open tracking) can trigger filters or feel intrusive to the recipient. |
When Light HTML Might Be Okay
If:
You’re sending to a warm list (e.g., post-event attendees)
The recipient already opted in (so it’s not truly cold)
Your domain reputation is strong and stable
...then a light HTML structure (like minor font styling or a single link) may be tolerated — but still keep it minimal.
Section 5: Where Marketing Meets Engineering - Turning Warm-Up Into a System
In most organizations, cold email warm-up sits awkwardly between marketing and IT. Marketers know it matters but often lack the tools. Engineers understand the infrastructure but rarely touch outreach strategy. That disconnect leads to broken pipelines, burnt domains, and underperforming campaigns.
But in a modern GTM (Go-To-Market) motion, email deliverability is not just a marketing issue - it’s an engineering challenge that demands process, tooling, and ongoing observability.
Here's how we bridge that gap in our team:
🎯 1. Treat Email Reputation Like Site Uptime
If your website goes down, you escalate it immediately. The same urgency should apply to deliverability drops. A 30% drop in open rate isn't "just a bad subject line" - it might be a broken SPF or blacklisted IP. We monitor key metrics (open %, bounce %, inbox vs spam placement) weekly.
🎯 2. Build a Dedicated Sending Infrastructure
We maintain separate subdomains for cold, nurture, product updates, and transactional sends. Each has its own reputation path. Cold outreach happens on structured warm-up routines, isolated from our brand’s core transactional flows.
🎯 3. Create Warm-Up Protocols Just Like CI/CD Pipelines
Our engineers have deployment pipelines - why shouldn’t our marketing team have sending pipelines?
Every new cold campaign follows a defined sequence:
Inbox creation → DNS configuration → Tool integration → Manual warm-up → Auto warm-up → Controlled outreach rollout
It’s a repeatable, measurable system, not a gut-feel launch.
🎯 4. Operationalize Feedback Loops
We feed bounce data, spam complaints, and engagement rates back into lead qualification. For example:
Leads who opened but didn’t reply → nurtured via soft-value email sequences
High-spam domains → suppressed from future cold lists
Cold campaign insights → routed into CRM for scoring and funnel planning
This ties RevOps, growth, and engineering into a shared accountability model.
🎯 5. Train Teams to Respect Reputation as an Asset
Everyone - SDRs, growth marketers, marketing ops - understands that the domain is a shared resource, not a disposable tool. Every cold email impacts not just the sender, but the brand’s future ability to reach inboxes at scale.
⚠️ Never blast emails from your main domain
Let’s unpack why you should never blast from your main domain and clarify whether cold emails can ever be sent manually from it.
Manually sending cold emails from your main domain is safe only if you keep it human, minimal, and ultra-personalized.
If done in repetition or scaled carelessly, it becomes just another risky blast, and inbox algorithms will catch on.
🔻 1. Reputation Risk
Mailbox providers like Gmail and Outlook track the reputation of domains at both IP and domain levels. If your cold emails:
get marked as spam,
generate high bounce rates,
or receive low engagement,
…your entire domain’s sender reputation drops.
That means:
Even your customer invoices may land in spam
Your support emails might not reach clients
Your job application replies may go unseen
Ya not a very good thing to happen
Think of it like credit history: one bad loan affects your future, even if it’s unrelated.
📉 2. Engagement Signals Get Diluted
When cold emails get low opens or no replies, those metrics feed back into your sender score. If you’re using your main domain for marketing automation or nurture, this overlap hurts deliverability across all your segments.
🔒 3. Domain Blacklisting
Too many cold emails from your main domain can get it:
Blacklisted on public spam databases (like Spamhaus, Barracuda)
Rate-limited or throttled by providers (e.g., Gmail might block further sends)
Auto-diverted to “Promotions” or “Spam” for even legitimate emails
Recovering from a domain blacklist can take weeks - and in some cases, is irreversible.
✅ So, Should You Ever Send Cold Emails from Your Main Domain - Even Manually? Yes, but only if the following conditions are met:
Criteria | Recommended Limit / Guideline |
Volume | Max 5–10 cold emails per day per sender from the main domain |
Frequency | Do not exceed 50 cold emails per week from your primary domain |
Engagement Expectations | Only do this if expected open rate is >40% and reply rate is >5% |
Personalization Level | Each email must be handwritten or hyper-personalized (not templates or sequences) |
Email Type | Must look like real 1:1 outreach - no buttons, multiple links, or design-heavy HTML |
Bounce Risk | Send only to validated, non-scraped emails (use tools like NeverBounce, ZeroBounce, etc.) |
Follow-Ups | 1–2 follow-ups max, and only if the first email wasn’t opened - spread 4–5 days apart |
Sending Time | Stagger across time slots - do not send all 10 at once |
🚫 If You Don’t Meet These Criteria - Treat It as Risky Behavior
Even if it's technically manual, consistently sending 10 low-engagement cold emails from your main domain daily is:
Statistically similar to low-grade spam from a provider’s point of view
A slow reputational bleed that will reduce inbox placement over weeks
Risky for your core transactional and nurturing email performance
Consider routing responses to your main inbox via alias or forwarding from other domains.
🧠 Here’s a Guiding Framework:
Scenario | Use Main Domain? | Reason |
Sending 1:1 pitch to investor or ex-colleague | ✔️ Yes | Relationship-based, highly contextual |
Sending to a small batch of 5–10 curated leads after an event | ✔️ Yes (if personalized) | Timely, relevant, likely to be opened |
Sending templated outreach to 50 people using CRM automation | ❌ No | That’s a cold campaign - use a warmed-up subdomain |
Doing cold outreach daily for top-of-funnel SDR activity | ❌ No | Use dedicated outreach domain & inbox rotation |
Following up with dormant leads who engaged 2–3 months ago | ✅ Yes (nurturing, not cold) | Warm leads, not true cold outreach |
Section 6: Appendix - Tools, Templates & Warm-Up Resources
Your cold email success depends not only on strategy but also on having the right infrastructure, tracking systems, and content discipline in place. This appendix curates proven tools and templates to help you implement and scale your warm-up process the right way.
🧰 A. Warm-Up, Outreach & Email Deliverability Tool Classification
Tool | Category | Warm-Up Capability | What It Does / When to Use |
MailReach | Warm-Up Tool | ✅ Yes | Automates warm-up with real inbox network, great for new or cold domains |
Lemwarm (Lemlist) | Warm-Up + Outreach | ✅ Yes | Warm-up built into Lemlist - useful if you’re using it for cold campaigns |
Warm-Up + Deliverability | ✅ Yes | AI-driven warm-up, inbox placement focused - ideal for fast ramp-ups or recovery | |
Cold Outreach Platform | ✅ Yes | Includes warm-up + multi-inbox sequencing - great for SDR and scale use | |
Cold Outreach Platform | ❌ No (external needed) | Lead sourcing + email sequencing - requires integration with a warm-up tool | |
ActiveCampaign | Marketing Automation | ❌ No | Best for nurturing warm leads through automated email flows, not cold outreach |
Mailchimp | Email Marketing (Nurture) | ❌ No | Used for newsletters and opt-in lists - not suitable for cold emailing or warm-up |
Google Postmaster Tools | Deliverability Monitoring | ❌ No | Tracks domain reputation, spam rate, inbox performance - essential for diagnostics |
GlockApps | Deliverability Testing | ❌ No | Tests spam scores, inbox placement - helps optimize content before big sends |
ZeroBounce / NeverBounce | Email Verification | ❌ No | Verifies email addresses to reduce bounce rates - critical before warm-up or campaigns |
🔄 Do You Still Need a Warm-Up Tool with tools like Apollo, MailChimp or ActiveCampaign?
Yes - absolutely, if you're setting up Apollo or any outreach tool, it's highly advisable to pair it with a dedicated warm-up tool like MailReach, Lemwarm, or Warmbox. Tools like Apollo focus on sequencing and outreach - they do not natively warm up your sending domain or inbox. If you start blasting cold emails from a freshly set-up Apollo account without warming up, you risk immediate spam classification or even domain blacklisting.
For platforms like ActiveCampaign, which are built for nurturing opt-in contacts, warm-up may still be important - especially if the domain is new or hasn't sent email at scale before. In such cases, run a basic warm-up phase for 2–3 weeks to build initial trust with inbox providers before starting automation workflows.
TL;DR: If you're using any new domain or email infrastructure - cold or warm - start with warm-up first, then scale outreach or nurture.
❓Is Manual Warm-Up a Viable Alternative to Automated Warm-Up Tools?
If you’re warming up a strategic outreach domain & new expense absolutely scares you to the core, start manual only if you have full control and discipline. But for ongoing ops or SDR teams, automated warm-up is a better investment - it's consistent, data-rich, and scales cleanly.
❌ Cons / Limitations
Not scalable - becomes unmanageable with >2–3 inboxes or domains
Time-consuming - requires daily effort and human replies
Easy to forget or do inconsistently - one skipped day or a few non-replies can slow reputation building
Limited data visibility - no dashboards or reputation scoring like MailReach or Warmbox
🚫 When to Avoid Manual
SDR teams or >2 inboxes involved
New domains that need rapid warm-up
You're launching a campaign within 2–3 weeks
You want real-time monitoring, metrics, or alerts
📊 B. Metrics That Matter During Warm-Up & Campaigns
Metric | Why It Matters | Ideal Range |
Basic Data Points | ||
Open Rate | Signals inbox placement | > 40% during warm-up |
Reply Rate | Indicates human interaction | > 5% for early outreach |
Bounce Rate | High bounce kills domain reputation | < 2% always |
Spam Complaint Rate | Heavy impact on reputation | < 0.1% |
Engagement Score (tool-specific) | Aggregate signal across open/reply/click | Green zone (safe) |
Derived Data Points | ||
Inbox Placement Rate (via GlockApps/Postmaster) | Shows what % of emails land in primary inbox vs promotions/spam | > 80% inbox, < 10% spam |
Positive Engagement Rate (Opens + Replies combined) | Higher engagement signals interest to inbox providers | Track trend line - must improve week over week |
Domain/IP Reputation (Google Postmaster Tools) | Your baseline score for Gmail and other services | Must stay in “High” or “Medium” (avoid “Low”) |
Send Volume Trend | Sudden spikes = red flag; consistency builds trust | Keep growth linear (~ -10% to 25% delta every few days) |
Blacklist Status (via MXToolbox, Talos, etc.) | Shows if your domain or IP is blacklisted anywhere | Should always be clear; check weekly during warm-up |
Email Client Diversity (for warm-up lists) | Diversity in recipient domains (Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, different domains, etc.) mimics real-world sending | Avoid sending only to one domain type (e.g., all Gmail) |
If 2–3 indicators start slipping (e.g., open drops <20% and bounces rise), pause sends, re-verify your config, and consider restarting warm-up.
👀 Extra Insights (for power users)
Engagement Lag: A drop in open rate with a time delay often signals you're gradually hitting spam, not instantly.
Soft Bounces: Can indicate temp blocks (e.g., “too many emails, try later”) - early warning sign of reputation issues.
Promotions Tab: For nurture campaigns, track Gmail tab placement - aim for Primary if possible, not just non-spam.
📋 C. Warm-Up Checklist
Use this checklist before launching any cold or nurture campaign from a new domain or inbox. This is not complete or exhaustive in any way, just take this as some key steps to check.
🛠️ 1. Domain & DNS Setup
✅ Domain is at least 2–3 weeks old (older is better)
✅ SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are set up correctly
✅ Reverse DNS (PTR) is configured (important for B2B domains)
✅ MX records point to the correct email service (e.g., Google, Outlook)
📧 2. Inbox Configuration
✅ Inboxes created with human-style names (e.g., sanjay@connectyourbrand.com)
✅ Profile photo, display name, and signature added to mimic real usage
✅ Connected to a sending tool (e.g., Apollo, Instantly, Lemlist, etc.)
✅ Optional: Two inboxes per domain for redundancy and rotation
📤 3. Warm-Up Routine (Manual or Automated)
✅ If manual: Send 10–15 non-salesy, real emails per day to known contacts who will reply
✅ If automated: Warm-up tool configured (MailReach, Lemwarm, Warmbox, etc.)
✅ Mix of recipient domains (Gmail, Outlook, custom business domains)
✅ Replies happening (ideally 20–30% of sent warm-up emails get replies)
📊 4. Monitoring & Adjustment
✅ Bounce rate is < 2%
✅ Open rate is > 40%
✅ No spam complaints (track with Postmaster Tools or warm-up platform)
✅ Daily volume increases gradually (no big jumps or large dips)
✅ Warm-up runs for at least 14–21 days before launching actual cold campaigns
💡 5. Pre-Launch Quality Check
✅ All email addresses are verified (via ZeroBounce or NeverBounce)
✅ No links or attachments in the first cold message
✅ Plain-text or light formatting only - no images, buttons, or fancy HTML
✅ Message copy is personalized and reads like a real 1:1 human message. Signals can help, check out - https://medium.com/@samrat_98433/f95a4cf2cc07
✅ Throttle volume - don’t send more than 100–150/ day per inbox at the start
🔄 6. Go-Live Transition
✅ Warm-up paused only after inbox is engaging reliably with 50–200 emails/ day
✅ Final domain/IP check on MXToolbox (ensure no blacklists)
✅ Start with most engaged or high-fit contacts to maintain deliverability momentum
✅ Cold leads are added in small daily batches (avoid bulk uploads/blasts)
✅ Monitor campaign performance daily for first 2 weeks
🧠 Optional - Organizational Best Practices (for IT Services Firms)
✅ Use separate subdomains/ domains for cold, nurture, and transactional emails
✅ Educate sales/BD/SDR/BOP teams on domain hygiene and risk
✅ Maintain a shared “Inbox Reputation Tracker” with open/reply/spam data
✅ Don’t recycle burned domains - retire and rewarm instead
✅ Align outreach volume with resource availability for follow-ups (avoid idle interest)
Comments